|
Domestic violence: The other side By DON CLAYBROOK Of the Advocate - Another arrest for domestic violence husband slaps wife, boyfriend punches out girlfriend, 290-pound pro football player throws 120-pound woman from balcony same old story, right? The male is always the aggressor and the female is always the victim. Not necessarily. According to some surveys, government statistic's confirm that almost 40 percent of all domestic violence victims in the United States are men. Shocked? Incredulous? Join the club. Most people would be dumbfounded by that statistic. Lori Bloom is not. She heads an organization in Fort Bragg called People's Alternatives to Violence (PAV) and has made it a crusade to change that stereotypical image, an image that stamps men as almost always the perpetrators of domestic violence.
The classic view Traditionally, violence by women against men has been viewed as minimal "It could not possibly have hurt him," or, it's justified as self-defense "She is the victim of his abuse." Many would contend that women have an easy way out in the "blame game" by claiming, "I am a victim of domestic violence and can do no wrong." Or, they claim, women cannot be guilty of domestic violence because they can assert little or no power and control over men. However, some experts in the field are beginning to view that logic as twisted. Domestic violence committed by men is typically viewed by women's victims' advocate groups as being characterized by a need on the man's part to assert power and control. Domestic violence might take the form of jokes and insults; or, it might involve mayhem or murder. Certainly the acts that constitute domestic violence range from the somewhat slight to the very severe, all serious. But the victims are not always women.
According to Bloom, men have traditionally been taught that it is
important to be right and to win even at the expense of others. To be
wrong or to back down is to be shamed. Domestic violence often occurs
when a man gets angry in what he perceives to be a threatening
situation. However, no one, male or female, states Bloom, deserves to
be abused or treated with disrespect.
A 'get tough' approach
Affirmative action (informed and motivated by the classic view on
domestic violence) has, in the opinion of many, led to laws that have
created a clear gender bias. That bias in turn has permeated law
enforcement's response to domestic conflict. A call to 911 brings out a
fleet of squad cars eager to carry out today's "tough" domestic
violence laws. The centerpiece of the domestic violence laws and the
resultant enforcement seems to be mandatory arrest. And, the person
arrested is almost always the man.
According to some men's advocacy groups, a "no drop" policy by
prosecutors has become popular because it is a great publicity tool
and because it also serves as a way to ensure more funding. The
supposed victim, the woman, either does not file charges; or, the facts
of the incident tend to point to her as the perpetrator of the domestic
violence. Still, prosecutors maintain a "no drop" policy and file
charges against the man.
Oftentimes, according to one men's advocacy group, domestic violence
is "whatever the man does that the woman doesn't like." He files for
custody of the children and she sees that as a "threat." He demands
that she stop having an affair and she calls the demand, "abuse."
According to Lisa Scott, founding member of TABS (Taking Action
against Bias in the System), "Any modern man not terrified of being in
a relationship with a woman has not been paying attention."
According to Scott, gender bias as promulgated by the federal
government is always "bias against women." There seems to be little
recognition that bias could conceivably be "bias against men."
The emerging view
Many experts are beginning to see gender bias as a two-way street, at
least a 60/40 street. And, if they are not up to speed in initiating
legislation that would reflect the 60/40 split, they are at least
fighting back and raising serious questions about the "gender bias" in
most domestic violence legislation and prosecution.
Bloom is one of those experts. Her resume is long and impressive and
she is imminently qualified to speak against alleged abuses in her
selected field. Her 52-week People's Alternatives to Violence classes
offer anger-management options to men who are ordered by the court to
undergo counseling as part of their sentencing.
The classes are also open to men not referred by the court but who
have chosen to eliminate physical and emotional violence in their
lives. Each must admit that he has been unable to deal with his anger
by himself and must agree that he wants to stop acting violently and
abusively toward others.
Each man in Bloom's PAV classes must agree to learn the root causes of
his anger and must also agree to take responsibility for his behavior.
For those men ordered by the court to complete the classes, the program
is considered an alternative, a privilege, and a diversion that allows
him to avoid harsher court penalties while getting real help for his
underlying problems. According to Bloom, there are no such classes on
the coast for women.
A still small voice
Domestic violence is one of the many scourges and blights on the face
of America. It perhaps can be compared to the American Civil War,
arguably the most "uncivil" war ever waged. Domestic violence is like
that. There is really nothing very domestic about it. It destroys
homes, families, relationships, and careers. It is certainly one
manifestation of a nation rife with violence.
Millions of Americans, men and women, are perpetrators/victims of
domestic violence every year in the United States. Literally thousands
in this country are becoming aware of the extent and nature of the
problem. And a handful of people who are paying attention are starting
to understand domestic violence as a "genderless" crime that requires a
"genderless" approach and solution. Lori Bloom is one of the latter.
|